Pinewood Derby Times Newsletter Volume 5 Issue 11

Pinewood Derby Times
Volume 5, Issue 11
February 22, 2006
In this Edition:

- Editor's Notes

- Feature Article - Pinewood Derby Timer Considerations

- Tips

- Newsletter Subscriber Specials

- Car Showcase

- Memory - First Year Racing

- Q&A

Editor's Notes

Reader Feedback "These photos were not staged, and we were all amazed. Three of theses cars were made with your speed axles and lubed with NyOil II (the boys are Webelo I brothers). The fourth (yellow car) was a precut kit from a craft store. The wheels and axles were not BSA approved, but the boy was brand new so we did not make a big deal of it. We have four scouts in the family, so pinewood derby racing is a major undertaking." - Jason, Blake and Phillip Williams

Photo Finish

"I just found your newsletter and love it. I wish I had all this information when my sons and I started scouting four years ago. We are starting to build our car for this year's race and we will use your tips to improve our car. I still remember our first race being a beginner to all of this, and threw together two cars for my sons. Our pack helps with getting cars to weight if the scout couldn't do it. I learned that year to not wait to have weight added. By the time they got to my son's cars they had ran out of lead to melt. They did not have any way of adding weight, so someone suggested using fishing weights held on with wood filler. We tried that so we could race the next day. They did not look pretty but my sons had fun anyway. Both cars finished in the middle of the pack. Over the next year we learned about the fine tips of making a winning car and finished in the top ten. I am reading the tips supplied in this year's newsletters and will hopefully improve our standing in the pack. My youngest son still has this year and next to get his name on our Pack's Derby plaque. I'll let you how we do this year after the race this month." - Randy Moisan

Back Issues Are you a new subscriber? Have you missed a few issues? You can start reading all of the back issues of the Pinewood Derby Times today by Clicking Here.

Questions If you have any questions about the Pinewood Derby Times, Maximum Velocity, or about building a pinewood derby car, please contact me at: info@maximum-velocity.com

5 Ounce Certified Test Weight Eliminate questions and issues at the weigh-in by verifying the accuracy of your scale using this certified test weight. Each weight is guaranteed to be 5 ounces ± 0.006 grams (0.0002 ounces).

5 Ounce Certified Test Weights are featured as a Newsletter Special this month.

DerbyDome - The DerbyDome is a high-quality case for safely displaying pinewood derby cars. It uses a patent-pending mounting system to keep the cars in place. The DerbyDome works with standard wheelbase cars (BSA and PineCar) with unmodified wheels. A custom label is available from the manufacturer.

The DerbyDome is featured as a Newsletter Special this month.

Feature Article

Pinewood Derby Timer Considerations
By Stu Ferguson

In about November of 1990, I looked into getting a Pinewood Derby Timer for my son’s Cub Scout pack. I studied the ads in the back of Scouting magazine (before the Internet), but those timers appeared to cost too much and do too little. So I decided to design a timer myself.

After that initial prototype, I debated with myself whether or not I should sell the timer to a larger market. I made a decision to offer the timer, and that is when Micro Wizard and Fast Track Timers began.

Timer Features

The key features I thought a timer should have were:

The results should be consistent and repeatable, and should display a tie if the finish is ambiguous (more on this below).

The results should be displayed at the finish line so that everyone can see them as the cars cross the finish line.

Nothing should touch the car at the finish line. We use a phototransistor and an infrared beam.

The finish line should be thin and tall, so everyone can see the cars as they cross the finish line.

To keep the apparatus simple, the electronics should be built into the finish line structure.

The whole package should look good.

The timer should be a stand-alone unit and not require a computer to function.

The timer should have the option to interface with a computer, so the race data can be stored and managed with software running on the computer. Although Micro Wizard did not offer any software to manage the races at the time, I felt this was an important option for the future.

Timer Accuracy Considerations

How fast of a timer is needed for accurately selecting the proper finish order? Clearly a 1/100th second resolution (like that of a stopwatch) is not fast enough, as it could only differentiate cars separated by a few inches. Human judges would do a better job. How about 1/10,000 of a second accuracy? Surely this would be best. Actually, this is really too fast and can result in misleading results. Why? Because of several factors:

Sensor Occlusion - Even when sensors are of the same type, slight variances exist between sensors as to the amount of occlusion (blockage) required before the sensor triggers. In addition to the sensor itself, the shape of the front of the car, the color of the paint, the height off the track, et al, also affect when the sensor will trip.

Sensor responsiveness - Similar to the above, other factors can affect the responsiveness of a sensor, causing slight variances from lane to lane. These include: temperature, air drafts, vibration, etc.

Sensor placement - Regardless as to the amount of care used when mounting the sensors, there are usually slight (thousandths of a inch) differences in sensor placement from lane-to-lane. This can lead to one or more lanes producing faster results.

Track issues -Track expansion and contraction, and other construction issues can lead to lanes being slightly longer or shorter. This produces faster results in certain lanes.

Start line issue - Similar to the above, the starting line can impart slight advantages to one or more lanes due to placement, drop speed, etc.

Given the above factors that affect performance, measuring to the ten-thousandths of a second (equating to less than 1/8 of an inch at the finish line) can produce erroneous results. So what is the best way to measure?

At Micro Wizard, we issue a tie whenever two cars finish within 0.0002 seconds of each other. Even though our sensors and sensor mounting are as accurate as possible, 0.0002 seconds is the closest measurement that can be determined with reasonable accuracy. Thus, any race where two cars are closer than 1/8 of an inch will result in a tie at the finish line.

About the Author

Stu Ferguson is the owner of Micro Wizard, which manufacturers timing equipment for Pinewood Derby racing. You can see the Micro Wizard offering at www.microwizard.com

Editor's Note

Referring to the photos in the 'Reader Feedback' section above, you can see why electronic timers are needed to judge a race. But you can also see why slight variances in the factors listed above could easily change the race results. Judge for yourself if there is a clear winner, or whether one or more ties should be issued in the race.

Tips

Submitted by Tim Randolph

Some other dads and I tested the dry white lube versus no lube after we finished setting up the track. One of the veteran dads brought some older cars to test the track and timing gear. We ran two runs with no lube with times of 3.3513 and 3.3512. Very consistent. Then we added the dry white lube. The next two runs were 3.4755 and 3.4769.

The next morning at the inspection and repair table, we shared this information with all of the entrants. Most of the cars had not been lubricated prior to coming in, but we used compressed air to clean out those that had used the dry white lube.

The bottom line: avoid the dry white lube. If your rules restrict you to using this lube, opt for using nothing.

If you have a tip you would like to share, please send it to: info@maximum-velocity.com

If your tip is used, you will receive a copy of Volume 5 of the Pinewood Derby Times when it is compiled during the summer of 2006. Don't worry about literary polish. We will edit it as needed before publishing. Also, please read our Submission Policy.

Special Offers for Newsletter Subscribers

5 ounce Certified Test Weight: $2.00 off
Eliminate questions and issues at the weigh-in by verifying the accuracy of your scale using this certified test weight. Each weight is guaranteed to be 5 ounces ± 0.006 grams (0.0002 ounces).

Note that this weight can be used to verify the accuracy of any scale, but may not function as a calibration weight for all scales.

For more information about 5 Ounce Test Weights Click Here.

but make sure to Purchase Here.

DerbyDome: $1.00 off
The DerbyDome is a high-quality case for safely displaying pinewood derby cars. It uses a patent-pending mounting system to keep the cars in place. A custom label is available from the manufacturer.

For more information about the DerbyDome, Click Here.

but make sure to Purchase Here.

These specials are valid through March 7, 2006.

Car Showcase

Reverse Wing: Paul & Jordan Messineo

Jordan and I decided to build the Wing upside down to have greater access to the weights. Since this was our attempt to try to win we were not sure how much time we would have if the car was under or over the limit. I was talking to Jordan about this concern, and Jordan said "Why don't we turn the car upside down to get to the weights." Well it worked. Jordan was the reason we won with that idea - at least I want to think so.

Silver Bullet: Jeff & Jack Jouett

Last year we built the Low-Rider and it finished second in the pack and (after some work) first in the district. This year we designed our own car. It will be a surprise as nobody has seen it yet. We had a few sons and fathers come to my shop to work on cars, but we kept Jack's tucked away. Jack likes the suspense, and can't wait to unveil his car. There are a lot of fathers and sons in the pack waiting to see what we came up with. I don't know how his car will finish, but I'll be very surprised if anyone beats him. He worked very hard on it and I think it is going to be a very fast car.

The Tank: Mark & Hunter Sensabaugh

The design idea for this car was totally from my son Hunter. He is 5-years old, so he must race in the adult division at our pack race. He really likes all things military, but especially tanks. When I asked him to decide what he wanted his car to look like, he said "a tank" without hesitation. We cut the block on both ends to leave the center section, then used a Dremel tool to round the top to make the turret. We then used a dowel rod for the barrel, drilling a hole in the turret and gluing it in with wood glue. We weighted the car internally using 3/8 inch lead weight by drilling holes through the body and then using wood filler to seal the holes. We used the Pro-Hub tool to polish and angle the hubs and the Pro-Body tool to relocate the axle holes to their farthest possible locations on the block. We used the other Pro-Tools as well. The weight placement had the car balanced about 1 and 1/4 inches in front of the rear axles. When we got to the race the official scale showed the car 0.15 grams light. That's when we added a lead piece on the top as the turret hatch which put the weight at 5 ounces. The tank came out smoking fast and was clearly outrunning the other adult built cars by about two car lengths. The only other car close was the scoutmasters, who ran a pretty close second. As they were calling the winners names my son said he wished he would win a trophy. Then about a minute later they announced him as the winner of the adult class. Needless to say the look on his face was worth a million dollars!

Share Your Pinewood Derby Car Creation
Do you have a car you would like to 'show off' to our readers? If so, send us a photo of your car along with a brief description of any special features. Please include your name, city and state. If selected, we will include the photo and description in this Car Showcase section. Please e-mail photos to:
info@maximum-velocity.com.

Photos must be sent by e-mail in JPG format (minimum size of 640x480 - maximum size of 1280 x 960). Please shoot photos from the front left of the car, similar to the orientation of the cars shown above.

Send only one photo per car, unless an additional photo is needed to adequately show a feature. Also, only one car per subscriber please. Thanks!

Pinewood Derby Memory

First Year Racing

I was eight years old when I participated in my first pinewood derby. My father carved a simple car with a pocket knife, I sanded it and installed the wheels. I remember not having any powdered graphite so all I could do for lubrication was to rub a pencil lead on the axle nails. I was so excited when race night came. I was even more excited when my car took first place. I received a small trophy that I remember clutching, not wanting to put it down. My father passed on just 4 short years later. The memories I have of him working on my car and the night at the races are some of the most treasured on my childhood. The trophy I won that night became one of my most prized possessions. Although I have moved many times and parted with many possessions, I still have my little blue and gold trophy.

Thirty years have passed now. Last year my own eight year old son, Jeffrey, found my pinewood trophy. He was in his first year of Cub Scouts. He loved my little trophy and wanted to try to win one of his own. I told him that winning wasn’t everything and that the real fun was in making and racing the car (but deep down, I remembered how excited I was when I had won when I was his age). So we decided we would work hard on his car for the upcoming race. We found a construction tip book and I got some friendly pointers from some of my friends who also had kids in scouts. Jeffery came up with a simple but sleek design. I cut the car with a jig saw and Jeffrey sanded it. We filed the burrs of the axles and smoothed the wheels. After lubricating the wheels and doing our best to make the car go straight, it was ready.

Race day came and I could see the excitement in my son’s eyes. His car ran six heats and won every one. He ended up third in his age group (based on total time) and 7th out of 75 scouts overall. Not bad for his first year. He received a medal for his third place finish (only the overall winner received a trophy). My son had fun, but he wanted to race again and have another chance to win a trophy. He decided to race his car in the district races to be held in 6 weeks time. In the mean time, we worked on his car, correcting an alignment problem with one of the front wheels. One of the wheels had come loose during the Pack race and now continually pulled the car to the side. We had to lift it off the track completely to make the car go straight.

There were several very fast cars at the district race. The track record was tied and then broken in the early heats. My son’s car performed well, winning every heat and tying the track record in the process - the wheel repair seemed to have worked. I knew his times were fast and we were on the edge of our seats when the winners from each age group were announced. My son won 1st Place for the Wolf age group. He was presented with a small blue and gold trophy much like mine. The smile on his face was priceless. After the awards were handed out for each age group, the top four cars in each age group were raced again to determine the overall winner. My son’s car won two of four heats and was just barely nosed out by less than an inch in the other two. But He won 1st Place overall in the district with the fasted combined four heat times. This time he won a bigger, all gold trophy. When he brought both trophies home to show his mother, I think he was the happiest kid on earth. I have since given him my trophy and all three are now proudly displayed in our home. We are now preparing for this year's pinewood derby race. Whatever the result, the memories of my son’s first year racing are unforgettable, for both him and myself.

Chris & Jeffrey Corron
Greenville, South Carolina

Do You Have a Pinewood Derby Memory to Share?
Now that many races have been completed, I am sure there are many stories to share. Please jot down your humorous, unusual, sad, or heart-warming pinewood derby tale and send it to: info@maximum-velocity.com

If your story is used, you will receive a free copy of Volume 5 of the Pinewood Derby Times when it is compiled during the summer.

Don't worry about literary polish. We will edit as needed, and review it with you before publishing. Also, please read our Submission Policy

Q&A

I am a Cub Scout Dad who has built about 10 cars now with varied success. Our cars have received trophies 5 times but the other 5 cars were duds. We still have 2 years of building left before we call it quits. I read an article today suggesting putting weight in the wheels as opposed to the body. Any comments on this?

This idea has been suggested a few times, but all of the testing I have seen has shown that weighted wheels can only benefit if the track is extremely long. What happens is that the weighted wheels cause the car to start slowly, but roll further. So on the typical length tracks, the car falls behind immediately and can never catch up.

In fact on the typical track, light-weight wheels produce faster times than heavier wheels. That is why people drill holes in sidewalls, undercut the tread, etc. This is also the main reason why the skinny outlaw-style wheels are so fast; they are extremely light.

How do you recommend properly polishing single-rod axles? Our kits are the type with single-rod axles and I am trying to figure out how to grip the axle in the chuck of a drill or Dremel tool without burring or marring the gripped surface (which is the opposite-ended surface for the other wheel). I don't want to un-do all the polishing on one end as I grip it to polish the other end.

I suggest cutting the axle in half. That way you can polish without issue, and you can better set the wheel hub to car body gap. If the axles are in one piece, then the body width defines the gap (not a good thing). Another benefit is that you now have the option to raise a front wheel.

Several years ago when I only had one of my boys in scouts, the rest of the family got to participate in the races and we bought pinewood car Kits from Hobby Lobby. The blocks of wood seemed to be made out of a less dense wood vs. the Official BSA block. The hobby shop cars consistently beat the cars that I've made in subsequent years. Is there an advantage to using a lighter block of wood assuming that it conforms to the BSA dimensions? I've theorized that it allows for a more concentrated weight placement.

Lighter blocks can be an advantage, as it allows you to be more precise when placing the weight. That is why pineheads oftentimes search for the lightest car kits (which of course have the lightest blocks). People also 'bake' blocks in an oven to reduce weight.

The hobby shop blocks you are referring to are probably PineCar-brand. The wood is poplar(1), which is a contradiction of terms since the company is PineCar!

(1) The light easily worked wood of the tulip tree; used for furniture and veneer.

Do You Have a Question?
Do you have a pinewood derby-related question? If so, send your question to: info@maximum-velocity.com. We answer all questions by e-mail, but not every question will appear in the Q&A section of the newsletter.

Back Issues

Are you a new subscriber, or have you missed some of the previous newsletters? Don't miss out! All of the issues for Volume 5 are posted on our web site:

Volume 5, Issue 1

Volume 5, Issue 2

Volume 5, Issue 3

Volume 5, Issue 4

Volume 5, Issue 5

Volume 5, Issue 6

Volume 5, Issue 7

Volume 5, Issue 8

Volume 5, Issue 9

Volume 5, Issue 10

Volume 5, Issue 11

Issues from the four previous seasons are available in four formatted volumes, ready for immediate download. To find out more, Click Here.

Newsletter Contributions

We welcome your contributions! If you would like to contribute an article, a web site review, or a speed tip, please send it to: info@maximum-velocity.com.

Please read our submission policy.

Subscription Information

The Pinewood Derby Times is a free e-newsletter focused on the Pinewood Derby. It is published biweekly from October through April.

Please Forward This Issue to a Friend

If you haven't already done so, feel free to forward this issue to your pinewood derby friends. Thanks!

Sign Up

If this newsletter was forwarded to you, why not subscribe to receive this newsletter. It is absolutely FREE and your e-mail address is safe, as we never release our distribution list.

Please don't subscribe your friends. Let them decide for themselves. Thanks.

To subscribe, enter your e-mail address below and press 'Subscribe'. You will be sent a confirmation e-mail. Reply to the e-mail to complete the subscription.

Randy Davis, Editor, Pinewood Derby Times
E-Mail: info@maximum-velocity.com

Copyright © 2006, Randy Davis. All rights reserved. Please do not reprint or place this newsletter on your web site without explicit permission. However, if you like this newsletter we grant permission, and encourage you to e-mail it to a friend.

The author disclaims any personal loss or liability caused by utilization of any information presented in this newsletter.

The Pinewood Derby Times is not specific to, and is not affiliated with the Boy Scouts, YMCA, Awana, or any other organization.

® Maximum Velocity! is a registered trademark of Maximum Velocity! Pinewood Derby Products.
Pinewood Derby, and Space Derby are registered trademarks of Boys Scouts of America. All other names are trademarks of their respective owners.

Mailing list services are provided by: www.mail-list.com