– Feature Article – Offset Weight Placement
– Pinewood Derby Car Showcase
Offset Weight Placement
The front to back location of the center of gravity of a pinewood derby car (the balance point) has received much attention. Several experiments have been implemented which clearly show that a rearward placement of weight provides more speed on the typical track.
However, the side to side location of the center of gravity has received much less attention. From a potential energy viewpoint, the side to side location would be immaterial. However, from an alignment viewpoint, it would seem that the best side to side location would be the location that equalizes the weight load on the rear wheels.
If the car is running on all four wheels, then the weight should be centered (left to right) on the car. Figure 1 shows this pictorially. The dashed line divides in half the rectangle connecting the four wheels. So, assuming the car is symmetrical left to right, weight would be centered around (or placed on) the dashed line.
Figure 1 – Center Weighting on a Four-Wheel Car
However, the situation changes considerably if the car is running on three wheels. In Figure 2, a three-wheeled car is shown. If a triangle is drawn between the three wheels, then the bisector of the triangle (dashed line) would be the line around which the weight of the car should be balanced. But note that quite a bit of the car (the front left section) and one wheel lie outside the triangle. So in order to balance the weight of the car around the dashed line, likely most of the added weight would need to be placed right of the dashed line. The actual placement would vary depending on the relative weight of the car body and the required ballast weight.
Figure 2 – Center Weighting on a Three-Wheel Car
Of course this is just theory. In practice, the frictional forces involved may be so large that left to right weight centering may make little to no difference in alignment or performance.
To test this, I constructed a car on which the ballast weight could be adjusted left or right. Two 3/8 inch holes were drilled from left to right through the rear of the car, and two 1/2 ounce threaded tungsten weights were inserted into each of the holes. The back of the car was made relatively tall so that the weights could extend out of the car on both sides without interfering with the wheels.
Figure 3 – Test Car With Weight Evenly Balanced on Rear Wheels
Figure 4 – Test Car with Weight Shifted Left
Figure 5 – Test Car with Weight Shifted Right
Next, the front dominant wheel was slightly adjusted so that the car would roll straight on an alignment board.
The weight was then adjusted both to the right and to the left to see what affect the weight position would have on alignment.
Surprisingly, the position of the weight had little to no effect on the alignment of the car. Regardless of the location of the weight, the car tracked within a two inch band on every run. The variance can be accounted for by the inability to place the car in the same exact position on every test.
Placing the weight such that the weight is evenly distributed on the rear wheels is the theoretical correct technique. However, a different placement will not have any significant effect on the performance of the car.
Pinewood Derby Car Showcase
Black Widow – Ashton Walden
This car belongs to my son Ashton, and was raced when he was a Tiger. He placed first in his class and went on to win Grand Champion. He also participated in the district race, placing third in his class. We are very proud of all his efforts.
TuSpek – Dave Amstutz
This is my latest car, TuSpek. It will be running in the new “Spec/Tuner Division” at PWDRacing.com in 2011. A minimal amount of modification is allowed, including sanding. The purpose of the division is for everyone to use the same specs and to “tune” the car to the best of their ability. It should provide for some really close racing!
The Bee – Tommy Grassia
This car is owned by my grandson Tommy. The car came in first place in his competition.
I bought the Pro Body Tool for Awana so I could precision drill the holes instead of using slots. Using the 3/32 bit (Awana axles) produced holes not snug enough. Using super glue was not productive and for the first time in many years, I had a wheel come off during racing. Any suggestions?
Regarding, the Pro-Body tool, the Awana axles are just slightly less than 3/32 inch. But unfortunately, there is no commercially available drill bit that exactly matches the Awana axles. The next smaller bit makes a hole that is much too tight. But I have had a lot of success using white glue (inserted with a toothpick) to hold in the axles. The glue is water based so it tends to swell the wood fibers, tightening up the hole. You can also tighten the hole by inserting water into the hole with a toothpick.
What is the weight of the “Official BSA Grand Prix Pinewood Derby Car Kit”? I guess my direct question is what is the maximum amount of tungsten that I could possibly need while being at the 5 ounce max total car weight?
That depends on two factors: the density of the block in the kit, and the amount of wood removed when making the car.
The blocks vary in density from 3 to 6 ounces. So if you were to make a car that used 1/3 of the block:
2 oz wood plus 0.5 oz wheels/axles = 2.5 oz Total
2.5 ounces of weight needed
1 oz wood plus plus 0.5 oz wheels/axles = 1.5 oz Total
3.5 ounces of weight needed.
I’m wanting to make a pinewood derby car using 1/2 inch brass tubing. Any added weight will consist of lead BB shot, placed inside the tubing. My thinking is that on the downward part of the track the free rolling shot will propel the car forward, and level out on the flat part of the track, making the weight ratio more even. My concern is that the rolling of the shot backwards on the flat portion will actually work the opposite as a brake effect. What are your thoughts or concerns on this matter?
Generally, you want the weight towards the rear of the car on the slope. Then when the car is on the flat, it would nice if the weight was a little closer to the middle of the car (to balance the load). However, if you load BBs in a tube, the BBs will roll to the front on the slope, the opposite of what you want.
Also, most rule sets state that all added parts must be affixed. Loose parts are not acceptable. So loose BB’s could result in a disqualification.